Posted in: Infrastructure,
by Gregg Laskoski on May 3, 2014 06:00 AM
Will the latest train disaster induce stricter safety standards for oil transit by rail? Might it compel approval of the Keystone XL pipeline?
There are more questions than answers following this week's disaster when a CSX Corp train carrying crude oil derailed Wednesday and burst into flames in downtown Lynchburg, Virginia. It spilled oil into the James River and forced 350 families to evacuate their homes.
In its second oil-train accident this year, CSX said 15 cars of a train traveling from Chicago to Virginia derailed. Fire that erupted on three of the cars was extinguished several hours later, the company said.
But three railroad cars, each weighing 100 tons, fell down an embankment into the river and were still leaking oil later that day, Lynchburg Mayor Michael Gillette told Reuters.
This is the sixth fiery derailment to occur in North America since a runaway train in Lac-Megantic, Quebec, derailed and exploded, killing 47 people last July. Another CSX train carrying crude oil derailed in Philadelphia in January, nearly toppling over a bridge.
The latest incident, a short distance from office buildings in the city of 77,000, brought more calls from environmentalists for stricter regulations on shipping crude oil by rail.
Containing the oil spill was the city's biggest concern as cleanup efforts began, Gillette added. The river flows into Chesapeake Bay.
The U.S. Department of Transportation said it was sending Federal Railroad Administration inspectors to the scene, and the Environmental Protection Agency said an official was heading there to help the state monitor air quality.
The origin of the cargo, the train's final destination and the cause of the accident were not known. One of the only oil facilities to the east of Lynchburg is a converted refinery in Yorktown, now a storage depot run by Plains All American. The company did not immediately reply to queries.
With more trains hauling crude and flammable liquids across North America, U.S. regulators are expected soon to propose new rules for more robust tank cars to replace older models; Canadian authorities did so last week.
"With this event, regulators could try to expedite the process, and they'll likely err on the side of the more costly safety requirements," said Michael Cohen, vice president for research at Barclays in New York.
Tougher rules could raise costs for companies that lease tank cars and boost business for rail-car makers.
Residents across the country have voiced concern about oil trains, often a mile long, passing near their communities, particularly in New York and the Pacific Northwest. Derailments have also occurred in North Dakota and Alabama.
In Virginia, environmental groups including the Sierra Club and the Chesapeake Bay Foundation have opposed expansion of crude-by-rail shipments through the region to the Yorktown terminal, which can handle 140,000 barrels per day. CSX's route through populated areas like Lynchburg and its proximity to the James River have been mentioned as special concerns.
In January, CSX Chief Executive Michael Ward told analysts the company planned to boost crude-by-rail shipments by 50 percent this year. He said the Jacksonville, Florida-based railroad was working with U.S. regulators to address safety concerns in light of recent derailments and fires.
New York's Governor Cuomo has already written a letter to President Obama asking him to 'overhaul federal safety regulations' for trains hauling oil.